Sustainable Intensification of Agriculture

There have been many definitions of Sustainable Intensification (SI). The term can mean different things to different people, according to their individual perspectives and goals. In a farming context, SI generally involves managing farmland to increase farm output and competitiveness, whilst protecting the countryside and enhancing environment and social benefits. 'Intensification' of farming should not be confused with 'intensive' farming. SI does not assume a shift from less to more intensive modes, or vice versa. Instead, farmland is managed to maximise outcomes across economic, environmental and social dimensions.

What constitutes SI may not always directly benefit those instigating change, nor produce a benefit on the same scale at which a change was made. What is measured as sustainable and beneficial using one scale or indicator may not be when using others.

SI can benefit people locally, for example increasing rural income; regionally, for example by improving air and water quality; or globally, for example by reducing greenhouse gas emissions from agricultural land. For SI to be effective, collaboration between the farming community, academia, industry experts and policy makers, is vital.

The Research Platform

The Sustainable Intensification Research Platform (SIP) was a multi-partner research programme comprising farmers, industry experts, academia, environmental organisations, policymakers and other stakeholders. Funded by Defra and the Welsh Government, the platform explored the opportunities and risks of Sustainable Intensification from a range of perspectives and landscape scales across England and Wales.SIP worked to develop ways of funding and conducting collaborative research for applying methods of sustainable intensification in agriculture.

SIP worked to develop ways of funding and conducting collaborative research for applying methods of sustainable intensification in agriculture:

  • Developing a community of practice - with stronger links between scientists, farmers, economists, eco-services, policymakers and other environmental and agricultural stakeholders
  • Utilising study farms to host research on farming systems and land management
  • Creating a data platform to enable access to data collected within the SIP projects for researchers, policymakers and other interested parties
  • Producing tools to help individuals and groups to identify existing SI opportunities that are appropriate to them while balancing different objectives and priorities in their delivery.

Mapping Opportunity and Risk: A Dynamic Landscape Typology Tool for England and Wales

The Dynamic Landscape Typology Tool for England and Wales classifies landscapes based on environmental and social-economic characteristics such as soil type, water quality, crop yield, farm economics, cultural and recreational values, and landscape and historical character. These are based on pre-existing sources of data and help policy makers and stakeholders understand opportunities and risks for food production and the environment. The Landscape Typology for England and Wales classifies landscapes based on physical and environmental and social-economic characteristics such as soil type, water quality and crop yield. These are based on pre-existing sources of data and help policy makers and stakeholders understand opportunities and risks for food production and the environment. 

The tool and further information can be found at the following link: https://eip.ceh.ac.uk/apps/sustainable-intensification/info/ 

A Science, Policy and Practice note is available here.

Image
Decision Support Tool

 

Making farms more sustainable: Decision Support Tools for Integrated Farm Management

Decision support systems make an important contribution to farming decisions, adding to the vital experience-based knowledge of farmers. The SIP looked at a broad range of decision support tools available to UK farmers and farm advisers, including bespoke software, tools based on generic software (e.g. Excel), email or text alerts, online tools and guidance, phone apps, and paper-based guidance.

The Project compiled a list of tools relevant to UK agriculture, and also conducted focus groups and interviews with farmers and farm advisers across the arable, dairy, and red meat sectors. Of particular interest were attitudes and the identification of key factors affecting the use of such tools in farming decisions.

The identification of these key use factors, and the highlighting of specific examples of effective tools, will help inform future policies about the design, communication, and use of decision support tools in UK agriculture.

The final report for this work can be found here.

The following papers are available:

  • Rose, D. C.,Sutherland, W. J., et al., Dicks, L. V. (2018). Integrated farm management for sustainable agriculture: lessons for knowledge exchange and policy, Land Use Policy, Full text (Open access)
  • Rose, D. C., Parker, C., Fodey, J., Park, C., Sutherland, W. J., and Dicks, L. V. (2018). Involving stakeholders in agricultural decision support systems: improving user-centred design, International Journal of Agricultural Management 6 (3-4): 80-89
  • Rose, D. C., Morris, C., Lobley, M., Winter, M., Sutherland, W. J., and Dicks, L. V. (2018). Exploring the spatialities of technological and user re-scripting: The case of decision support tools in UK agriculture, Geoforum 89 pp. 11-18, Full Text (Open access)
  • Rose, D. C., Bruce, T. A. J. (2017) Finding the right connection – what makes a successful decision support system?, Food and Energy Security, Full Text (Open access)
  • Rose, D. C., Sutherland, W. J., Parker, C., Lobley, M., Winter, M., Morris, C., Twining, S., Ffoulkes, C., Amano, T., Dicks, L. V. (2016) Decision support tools for agriculture: Towards effective design and delivery, Agricultural Systems 149 pp. 165-174 Full Text (Open access)